• 0 Posts
  • 44 Comments
Joined 20 days ago
cake
Cake day: May 11th, 2025

help-circle
















  • The Black Panther Party were cool, but the PSL is a bad example, imo. They’ve had… issues. Really icky issues that kind of mar the whole organization. I did meet some cool former PSLers back in my DSA-LSC days, though.

    I think it’s personally a stretch to call Xin Jinping a Marxist, even if that’s how he identifies. It kind of seems like China’s just doing a capitalism, but with more steps. I don’t know enough about Vietnam and Cuba, but it’s my understanding that Vietnam has been slowly moving in the same state capitalist direction that China did


  • All of the examples I listed should meet your definition of success, right?

    You said:

    The nature of society has not fundamentally changed in a century, so there’s no reason to think that methods of organization need to drastically change as well.

    I said:

    You don’t actually believe that basically nothing has changed since before the industrial revolution, do you? That seems intentionally obtuse.

    How is that a straw man? It’s literally what you said.



  • To date, nobody has shown a more effective approach to organizing that I’m aware of.

    Makhnovshchina, CNT, Rojava, Zapatistas…

    Is your definition of success the establishment of a socialist state? Because anarchists are never going to do that.

    The nature of society has not fundamentally changed in a century

    You don’t actually believe that basically nothing has changed since before the industrial revolution, do you? That seems intentionally obtuse.